States and municipalities are increasingly attempting to use climate nuisance litigation to hold fossil fuel companies such as BP, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, Exxon Mobil, and Royal Dutch Shell, accountable for climate change. Climate plaintiffs across the country are requesting a total of approximately two hundred billion dollars in damages. If these plaintiffs manage to win their lawsuits, defendants simply do not have the cash flow to pay such large damage awards. Defendants’ principal assets are associated with fossil fuel reserves, so extracting oil and gas resources as a method of paying damages would exacerbate climate change. As a result, the oil and gas companies could be compelled to file for bankruptcy. In either the sale of the companies or their assets, defendants would be transferring their oil and gas resources to other fossil fuel companies, whose actions would further cause detrimental effects to the environment. Additionally, in the bankruptcy context, climate plaintiffs would be considered unsecured creditors and would be paid out only after the secured creditors receive their full payments, so they may not even be paid sufficiently. Therefore, if plaintiffs overcome their obstacles in litigation and reach the discovery stage, the best outcome is for the parties to form a Master Settlement Agreement. Plaintiffs would agree to drop their lawsuits, and defendant oil and gas companies would agree to increase their use of renewables, transition away from fossil fuels, and leave a certain portion of unburnable carbon in the ground.
Download the PDFMore HRLR Online
TRUST ISSUES: MILITARIZATION, DESTRUCTION, AND THE SEARCH FOR A REMEDY IN THE MARSHALL ISLANDS
Trust Issues: Militarization, Destruction, and the Search for a Remedy in the Marshall Islands Shannon Marcoux Table of Contents Introduction 100 I. United States Presence in the Marshall Islands: Historical Harm and Current Crises 103 A. New Name, Same Game: U.S. Colonization Becomes U.S. Trusteeship in the Marshalls 104 B. Slums and Suburbs: Displacement, Overcrowding,…
THIRD PARTY AT THE TABLE: AFRO-COLOMBIAN WOMEN’S STRUGGLE FOR PEACE AND INCLUSION
Third Party at the Table: Afro-Colombian Women’s Struggle for Peace and Inclusion Lisa Davis Table of Contents I. Colombia’s Historic Peace Accord 364 II. Third Party at the Table 365 A. The Accountability Question 369 B. Opposition to Gender 372 C. A Closer Look at Gender in the Accords 375 D. Organizing at the Intersection…
THE ANATOMY OF A FEDERAL TERRORISM PROSECUTION: A BLUEPRINT FOR REPRESSION AND ENTRAPMENT
Table of Contents I. Federal Anti-Terrorism Operations in the Wake of September 11, 2001 61 II. Counter-Terrorism Surveillance and the Information-Sharing Environment 63 A. Surveillance Without a Factual Predicate 65 B. Suspicious Activity Reporting 67 C. The Information-Sharing Environment and Fusion Centers 69 III. Weaving the Web of Informants and Provocateurs 71 IV. Agent Provocateurs…