States all over the world are enacting new laws that criminalize insults, and using existing insult laws with renewed vigour. In this article, we examine state practice, treaty provisions, and case law on insulting speech. We conclude that insulting speech is currently insufficiently protected under international law and regulated by confused case law and commentary. We explain that the three principal international treaties that regulate speech provide conflicting guidance on the right to insult in international law, and the treaty provisions have been interpreted in inconsistent ways by international courts and United Nations bodies. We conclude by recommending that international law should recognize a “right to insult” and, drawing on US practice under the First Amendment, we propose eight recommendations to guide consideration of insulting speech in international law. These recommendations would promote coherence in international legal standards and offer greater protection to freedom of speech.
Download the PDFMore HRLR Online
Not So Sweet: Sugarcane Burning, Florida’s Right-to-Farm Act, and Unconstitutional Takings
Not So Sweet: Sugarcane Burning, Florida’s Right-to-Farm Act, and Unconstitutional Takings Grace Coleman Table of Contents Introduction 2 I. The Everglades 5 A. History of the Everglades 5 B. The Everglades Today 8 C. Sugarcane Production 10 1. Sugarcane Burning Negatively Impacts Human Health 13 2. Sugarcane Burns in the Everglades Agricultural Area Have Discriminatory…
Death Wish: Standards for Deciding to Waive Eighth Amendment Protections Against Cruel and Unusual Manners of Execution
Death Wish: Standards for Deciding to Waive Eighth Amendment Protections Against Cruel and Unusual Manners of Execution Lauren Goff Table of Contents Introduction 3 I. Challenging Methods of Execution and Waiving Eighth Amendment Rights 8 A. Eighth Amendment Analysis of Methods of Execution 8 B. Waiver of Eighth Amendment Rights and the Right to Be…
Starved for Justice: International Complicity in Systematic Violations of the Right to Food in Haiti
Starved for Justice: International Complicity in Systematic Violations of the Right to Food in Haiti Sandra C. Wisner Abstract A series of international economic assistance programs in Haiti has led to a protracted and worsening food crisis in the country, amplifying the country’s vulnerability to starvation and malnutrition, as well as natural disasters, like earthquakes…