The Emerging Doctrine of State/Municipal Liability

Download the PDF

Martin Lockman is a 2019 graduate of Columbia Law School.

This Note contributes to the literature in three ways. Part I of this Note defines and describes the targeted context, provides examples of state/municipal delegation, discusses the underlying tension between vindicating federal rights and respecting states’ rights to structure their own internal governance, and observes that courts have taken a nuanced approach to resolving this tension analogous to § 1983’s standards supervisory liability. Part II describes judicial approaches to state/municipal liability and analyzes two proposed theoretical frameworks. Part III examines the history and function of § 1983’s “supervisory liability” standards, looks at recent state/municipal delegation cases through the lens of supervisory liability, and argues for the adoption of an analogous standard to govern state/municipal delegation.

Download the PDF

More H.R.L.R.

Swallowing Razors, Gouging Their Eyes Out:The Detainee Treatment Act and Eighth Amendment Protections for Asylum Seekers in Segregated IsolationSwallowing Razors

Alcira Hava

Human Rights in the Constitutional Era of Dobbs

Katharine G. Young

Who Shall Bear This Burden? Using Burden-Shifting to Disrupt Impunity for the Systematic Use of Enforced Disappearance

Michael Weaver
See all